top of page

Emotional Regulation: Why Some Children Struggle to Manage Big Feelings

9 minutes ago
12 min read

Understanding emotional development, frustration, resilience and the skills children need to manage their feelings.


An educational perspective for Australian parents


Why can a child become so upset over something that seems relatively insignificant to an adult?


A game doesn't go their way. A friend doesn't invite them to play. They are asked to turn off their iPad. Their homework becomes difficult. A parent says no. A teacher asks them to correct a mistake.


Suddenly, a seemingly ordinary situation becomes a significant emotional event.

Some children become frustrated, others withdraw, argue, cry or refuse to participate. Some struggle to explain what is wrong, while others seem unable to move beyond the emotion they are experiencing.


For parents, these situations can be exhausting. It can feel as though every small disappointment becomes a major negotiation.


You might find yourself saying:

  • "It's not that big a deal."

  • "You can't get upset every time something doesn't go your way."

  • "You need to learn to accept no."

  • "You can't always have things your way."

  • "Why are you getting so upset?"

  • "You need to calm down."


But here is something important to consider.

Children are not necessarily choosing to have difficulty managing their emotions. They may simply not have developed the skills required to manage them yet.


Emotional regulation is a developmental skill. Like reading, writing, problem-solving and executive functioning, it requires teaching, modelling, practice and support.

Understanding this changes how we respond to children when emotions become difficult.


It also helps us recognise the difference between allowing children to experience their feelings and teaching them that every feeling needs to dictate their behaviour.


1. What is emotional regulation?

Emotional regulation is the ability to recognise, understand and manage emotional responses.


It does not mean being happy all the time, avoiding frustration or never becoming upset.

It means developing the ability to experience an emotion without allowing that emotion to completely determine how we behave.


For example, a child who is disappointed about losing a game might initially feel frustrated. However, with developing emotional regulation skills, they can gradually learn to acknowledge that disappointment, manage their response and continue participating.


A child who is told they cannot have something might feel angry. Emotional regulation helps them understand that anger is an acceptable feeling, but that it does not give them permission to speak disrespectfully or disregard boundaries.

These are important distinctions.


Children need to understand that:

  • All feelings are valid.

  • Not all behaviours are acceptable.

  • Disappointment is a normal part of life.

  • Frustration does not mean something is unfair.

  • Making a mistake does not mean they have failed.

  • Being told no does not mean they are being treated badly.


Emotional regulation is not about suppressing emotions.

It is about learning how to respond to them appropriately.


The Australian Raising Children Network explains that children develop emotional regulation gradually, with adults playing an important role in helping them recognise, understand and manage their feelings.

This development takes time and varies between children.


2. Why do some children react so strongly?

Have you ever watched a child become extremely distressed over something that, from an adult's perspective, seems relatively minor?


Perhaps their sibling touches something they are using, they lose a game or they are asked to stop an activity.

The reaction can seem disproportionate to the situation.


However, children do not always have the developmental maturity or experience to interpret and manage their emotions in the same way adults do.

Several factors can contribute.


Developing brain connections

The brain systems involved in emotional responses, impulse control, planning and decision-making continue developing throughout childhood and adolescence.

The prefrontal cortex plays an important role in planning, decision-making and regulating behaviour. These abilities develop gradually.

This helps explain why children may understand what they should do but still struggle to manage their response when they become frustrated or overwhelmed.


Limited experience managing disappointment

Children need opportunities to experience disappointment and learn how to move through it.

If adults consistently remove obstacles, change expectations or provide immediate solutions whenever a child becomes upset, children may have fewer opportunities to practise managing difficult feelings.

This does not mean deliberately making children unhappy.

It means recognising that manageable disappointment is part of growing up.


Tiredness, hunger and overstimulation

Emotional regulation is influenced by a child's overall wellbeing.

Poor sleep, hunger, busy schedules, excessive stimulation, anxiety and environmental demands can all make it harder for children to manage their responses.

A child who has had a long day may have less capacity to manage frustration than they would after adequate rest.


Temperament and individual differences

Some children are naturally more sensitive to changes, uncertainty, disappointment or sensory experiences.

Others may experience difficulties associated with ADHD, autism, anxiety or other developmental differences.

Understanding the individual child is important.

We should avoid assuming that every emotional reaction has the same explanation.


The behaviour we see is only part of the picture. Understanding what is contributing to it helps us respond more effectively.


3. The difference between emotional regulation and getting your own way

This is an important conversation for parents.

Children need to feel safe expressing emotions. They also need to understand that experiencing an emotion does not mean they automatically get the outcome they want.


Consider this example.

A child asks to play a video game. Their parent says no because it is time to complete homework.

The child becomes frustrated and argues that it is unfair.

There are two separate issues here:

  1. The child is disappointed and frustrated.

  2. The child needs to understand and accept the boundary.


We can acknowledge the first without changing the second.

A parent might respond:

"I understand you're disappointed. You were hoping to play your game. However, homework needs to be completed first."


This response recognises the child's feelings while maintaining the expectation.

It is important that children learn:

  • They can disagree respectfully.

  • They can feel disappointed without becoming disrespectful.

  • They can express frustration without changing the rules.

  • They can accept decisions they do not necessarily like.

  • They are responsible for their behaviour, even when emotions are difficult.


Emotional validation is not the same as giving in.

We can acknowledge a child's feelings without agreeing with their behaviour or changing an appropriate boundary.


4. Co-regulation: Children learn emotional regulation through relationships

One of the most important concepts in child development is co-regulation.

Co-regulation describes the process through which adults help children manage their emotions and behaviour.


When children are young, they rely heavily on adults to help them settle, understand their feelings and respond to difficult situations.

Over time, through repeated experiences, children begin developing their own strategies.


The Harvard Center on the Developing Child identifies responsive relationships and supportive environments as important foundations for the development of self-regulation.


Think about what happens when a young child becomes upset.

A calm adult might:

  • Acknowledge what has happened.

  • Use a reassuring tone.

  • Help the child identify their feelings.

  • Reduce unnecessary demands while the child is overwhelmed.

  • Offer appropriate support.

  • Revisit the situation once the child is ready.


These experiences help children develop an understanding of their emotional responses.


However, co-regulation does not mean adults need to remove every source of frustration or solve every problem.

It means providing enough support for children to gradually learn how to manage situations themselves.


As children become older, the balance should gradually shift from adults managing emotions for them towards children taking greater responsibility for their own responses.

The ultimate goal is self-regulation.


5. Why telling children to "calm down" rarely works

When a child is upset, adults often want the behaviour to stop as quickly as possible.

We might say:

"Calm down."

"Stop crying."

"You're overreacting."

"There's nothing to be upset about."

Although these responses are understandable, they do not necessarily teach children what to do with the emotions they are experiencing.


Telling a child to calm down does not automatically give them the skills to regulate themselves.

A more helpful approach is to acknowledge the feeling, maintain appropriate expectations and provide guidance.


For example:

Instead of:

"Stop getting upset. It's only a game."

Try:

"I can see you're disappointed that you lost. Losing can be frustrating. Let's take a moment, and then we can talk about what happened."

Instead of:

"There's nothing to be angry about."

Try:

"You're feeling angry because things didn't happen the way you wanted. It's okay to feel angry, but we still need to speak respectfully."

Instead of:

"Just get on with your homework."

Try:

"This task feels difficult at the moment. Let's work out which part you can start with."

The language we use matters.

It helps children develop the vocabulary to understand their experiences and provides examples of how to respond when emotions become challenging.


6. Resilience: Why children need to experience disappointment

Resilience is often discussed as though it is a personality trait that some children naturally possess.


However, resilience is also developed through experience.

Children need opportunities to encounter manageable challenges, experience disappointment and learn that they can work through difficult situations.


Think about everyday childhood experiences:

  • Losing a board game.

  • Not being selected for a team.

  • Having to wait for something they want.

  • Making a mistake in their schoolwork.

  • Having a disagreement with a friend.

  • Finding a task more difficult than expected.

  • Being told they cannot do something.

These experiences can be uncomfortable, but they also provide opportunities to develop coping skills.


If adults consistently intervene to prevent children from experiencing disappointment, children may have fewer opportunities to practise managing it.

This does not mean ignoring distress or deliberately creating difficult situations.

It means allowing children to experience normal frustrations while providing appropriate support.


Psychologist Dr Martin Seligman, a leading researcher in positive psychology and learned optimism, has explored how explanatory thinking influences children's responses to setbacks.


His work highlights the importance of helping children develop more constructive ways of interpreting challenges.


For example, there is a significant difference between:

"I failed this test. I'm terrible at maths."

And:

"I didn't understand some of the questions. I need to practise those areas."

The second response helps a child recognise that a disappointing result is an experience they can learn from, rather than a permanent reflection of their ability.


Resilience is not about avoiding difficult feelings. It is about developing the confidence and skills to work through them.


7. Emotional regulation and the modern digital environment

There is another important consideration for parents.

Children are growing up in an environment where entertainment, communication and stimulation are constantly available.


Digital platforms can provide immediate rewards, predictable entertainment and opportunities to disengage from uncomfortable feelings.

Consider what happens when a child is bored, frustrated or disappointed.

A device may offer an immediate distraction.


While occasional distraction is not necessarily harmful, children also need opportunities to learn how to manage uncomfortable emotions without automatically escaping into entertainment.


For example, a child who becomes frustrated with homework may immediately seek their device. A child who feels lonely may turn to online entertainment. A child who is bored may struggle to identify an activity without a screen.


The concern is not that screens directly cause poor emotional regulation. The relationship is more complex.


However, parents should consider whether children are developing a range of strategies for managing their feelings, or whether digital entertainment has become their default response to boredom, frustration and discomfort.


Children need opportunities to practise:

  • Waiting.

  • Managing disappointment.

  • Solving problems.

  • Communicating feelings.

  • Accepting boundaries.

  • Finding alternative activities.

  • Returning to a task after becoming frustrated.

These are important life skills.


8. Emotional regulation in the classroom

Emotional regulation has a significant impact on children's learning and relationships at school.

A child who struggles to manage frustration may find it difficult to persist with challenging work.

A student who becomes overwhelmed by mistakes may avoid tasks that require effort.

A child who struggles with disappointment may find friendship disagreements particularly difficult.

A student who has difficulty managing impulses may interrupt others or respond before thinking.


These behaviours can affect more than academic progress.

They influence friendships, collaboration, classroom participation and a child's sense of belonging.


In the classroom, educators often support emotional development through:

  • Explicit teaching of emotional vocabulary.

  • Predictable routines and expectations.

  • Opportunities for reflection.

  • Restorative conversations.

  • Modelling respectful communication.

  • Teaching problem-solving strategies.

  • Helping students identify what they can control.

  • Encouraging students to take responsibility for their actions.

It is important that children understand both their rights and their responsibilities within a learning community.


They have the right to feel safe, respected and supported.

They also have a responsibility to treat others with dignity, follow reasonable expectations and manage their behaviour appropriately.

Emotional development and personal responsibility need to grow together.


9. Practical ways parents can help develop emotional regulation

Emotional regulation is developed through everyday interactions.

Parents do not need to wait for a major emotional incident to begin teaching these skills.


Here are some practical strategies.

1. Help children identify their emotions

Children need language to describe what they are experiencing.

Instead of simply asking, "What's wrong?", try:

  • "Are you feeling disappointed?"

  • "Did that make you frustrated?"

  • "Are you worried about what might happen?"

  • "Are you feeling left out?"

Help children recognise that different emotions can occur in the same situation.


2. Model emotional regulation

Children learn a great deal from watching adults.

If we become frustrated and respond by shouting, criticising or losing control, children see those behaviours modelled.

We do not need to be perfect.

However, we can demonstrate how to acknowledge frustration, pause and respond appropriately.


3. Maintain consistent boundaries

Children need to understand that boundaries do not disappear simply because they become upset.

Be empathetic, but remain consistent.

For example:

"I understand that you are disappointed, but the answer is still no."


4. Teach practical calming strategies

Different strategies work for different children.

These might include:

  • Taking a short break.

  • Slow, comfortable breathing.

  • Going for a walk.

  • Drawing or writing about feelings.

  • Listening to calming music.

  • Talking to a trusted adult.

  • Spending a little time in a quieter environment.

Practise these strategies when children are calm, rather than introducing them for the first time during a difficult moment.


5. Encourage problem-solving

Once a child is ready to talk, help them consider what happened and what they might do differently next time.

Ask:

  • What happened?

  • What were you feeling?

  • What could you do differently?

  • What might help next time?

The aim is to develop reflection rather than simply revisit the behaviour.


6. Allow manageable disappointment

Not every disappointment needs to be fixed.

Children can learn to cope with not always getting their preferred outcome.

Offer support, but avoid automatically changing a decision simply because a child becomes upset.


7. Recognise effort and progress

Acknowledge when children manage a difficult situation more successfully.

For example:

"I noticed you were disappointed, but you took some time and then came back to finish your work. That was a good way to manage the situation."

Be specific about the behaviour you want to encourage.


8. Protect sleep and establish predictable routines

Sleep, physical activity, nutrition and predictable routines all contribute to children's ability to manage everyday demands.

A tired or overwhelmed child may find emotional regulation more difficult.

Supporting overall wellbeing is an important part of supporting emotional development.


10. When emotional difficulties may need further support

All children experience strong emotions.

However, if emotional difficulties are persistent, significantly interfere with everyday life or affect relationships and learning, it may be worth seeking further advice.


Consider speaking with your child's teacher and GP if you notice:

  • Frequent and intense emotional reactions.

  • Persistent difficulty managing frustration.

  • Significant difficulties with transitions.

  • Ongoing anxiety or withdrawal.

  • Challenges maintaining friendships.

  • Emotional responses that regularly interfere with learning.

  • Difficulty recovering from everyday disappointments.


There may be several contributing factors, including developmental differences, ADHD, autism, anxiety, sleep difficulties or other emotional and learning needs.

A child who struggles with emotional regulation is not necessarily being deliberately difficult.

They may need additional support, explicit teaching or adjustments to help them manage everyday situations.

Seeking professional advice can help parents better understand their child's individual needs.

Alternatively, If you’d like to explore more practical resources, visit our Neurodiversity and Learning Support resources.


11. Raising children who can manage their emotions, not avoid them

Perhaps one of the most important lessons we can teach children is that life will not always go their way.

They will experience disappointment.

They will make mistakes.

They will encounter people who disagree with them.

They will sometimes have to wait, compromise, accept boundaries and work through situations they would rather avoid.

These are normal parts of growing up.


Our responsibility as parents and educators is not to protect children from every uncomfortable feeling.

It is to help them develop the skills to manage those feelings in healthy and appropriate ways.


We need to acknowledge emotions without allowing them to dictate every decision.

We need to provide support without removing responsibility.

We need to encourage resilience without dismissing genuine distress.


And we need to remember that emotional regulation is not something children simply know how to do. It is something they learn through relationships, experiences, modelling and practice.


The goal is not to raise children who never become upset, frustrated or disappointed. It is to raise children who understand their emotions, take responsibility for their responses and develop the confidence to navigate life's challenges.


Perhaps the next time your child becomes upset because something hasn't gone their way, consider asking yourself:

Am I trying to make this feeling disappear, or am I helping my child develop the skills to manage it?

Because there is a significant difference.

And it is often in those everyday moments of frustration, disappointment and challenge that some of the most important learning takes place.


Further reading and professional resources

The following Australian and international resources provide further information about emotional development, self-regulation and resilience.

1. Harvard University – Center on the Developing Child

Executive Function & Self-Regulation

Explains the development of self-regulation and the importance of supportive relationships and experiences.

2. Raising Children Network – Australian Parenting Website

Emotions and emotional development

Provides practical guidance for parents supporting children's emotional development and self-regulation.

3. Emerging Minds – National Workforce Centre for Child Mental Health

Provides Australian resources about children's emotional wellbeing, mental health and the importance of relationships.

4. Australian Psychological Society

Information and resources about children's mental health, emotional development and psychological wellbeing.

5. Beyond Blue

Children and young people

Information for parents about recognising emotional and mental health concerns and accessing appropriate support.

6. Martin Seligman – Positive Psychology and Learned Optimism

Research and resources exploring resilience, optimism and the ways children interpret and respond to setbacks.

Educational perspective: This article provides general information about child development and emotional wellbeing. It is not intended to diagnose developmental or mental health conditions or replace individual medical or psychological advice. Children's emotional development varies, and some children require additional support.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page